PRARAM 9 HOSPITAL PUBLIC COMPANY LIMITEDSET: PR9🇹🇭 TH

Risk Management · 2024

Risk Management Policy & Plan

Policy & Plan Description

Risk Management

Risk Management Policy and Governance (GRM 01, 02, 05, 07)

Praram 9 Hospital Public Company Limited carries out risk management in accordance with the risk policy, which is continuously refined based on the evolving business model. In 2024 onwards, the Enterprise Risk Management (ERM) policy of the Hospital encompasses 5 risk categories, namely: 1) Emerging Risk 2) Business Risk 3) Clinical Risk 4) Environmental, social, and governance (ESG) Risk 5) Shareholder Risk. Each risk category is overseen by the relevant committees, along with senior executives and risk owners, to manage the risks, mitigating them in acceptable levels. This is outlined as follows: (GRM 01, 02, 05, 07)

Roles and Responsibilities of the Board of Directors

Responsible for setting policies and making overall decisions, as well as approving or proposing improvements to risk information across 5 risk categories. These have been approved by the Audit Committee and the Enterprise Risk Management Committee to ensure their adequacy and alignment with the Company's strategic direction.

Roles and Responsibilities of the Audit Committee

Responsible for acknowledging and providing opinions on enterprise-wide risks across 5 risk categories, as well as recommending improvements to the risk management system to align with the principles of the 3 Lines of Defense, which are integrated with internal control and internal audit processes.

Roles and Responsibilities of the Enterprise Risk Management Committee

Oversee, supervise, and approve risk analysis and risk management approaches across 5 risk categories to ensure adequacy in achieving the Hospital’s vision and mission. Additionally, support and promote the development of a risk-aware culture across the organization through a structured knowledge-sharing approach.

Roles and Responsibilities of Senior Executives

Support the operational mechanisms of the Enterprise Risk Management Committee and act as risk owner, responsible for risk analysis, designing response strategies, and systematically developing Key Risk Indicators-KRIs.

Roles and Responsibilities of the Risk Management Division

The Hospital has established the risk management division with the primary responsibility of implementing enterprise-wide risk management in accordance with the international COSO ERM framework (Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission, Enterprise Risk Management). It also serves as a facilitator for risk owners to ensure risk management efforts achieve their goals. Additionally, it acts as the main unit for promoting a risk-aware culture and developing the Risk Champion system.


International Standards for Enterprise Risk Management (ERM) (GRM 04)

Praram 9 Hospital Public Company Limited emphasizes enterprise risk management (ERM). The Hospital's risk management process follows the international standard of COSO ERM 2017, consisting of 5 key components and 20 sub-principles, as illustrated below.

1. Governance and Culture

Comprising a Board of Directors, an Audit Committee, and a Risk Management Committee with clearly defined responsibilities (GRM 01, 02) as well as senior executives and personnel at all levels of the Hospital, who prioritize and implement risk management procedures. Furthermore, the Hospital has a risk management policy, a risk management manual, and risk management reports, along with initiatives to raise awareness of risk management across the Company. These are based on 5 principles: (1) Exercises Board Risk Oversight, (2) Establishes Operating Structures, (3) Defines Desired Culture, (4) Demonstrates Commitment to Core Values, and (5) Attracts, Develops, and Retains Capable Individuals.

2. Strategy and Objective Setting

The Hospital integrates risk management with the Company’s core strategies and objectives. This process consists of 4 principles: (6) Analyzes Business Context, (7) Defines Risk Appetite, (8) Evaluates Alternative Strategies, and (9) Formulates Business Objectives

3. Performance

consists of 5 principles: (10) Identifies Risk, (11) Assesses Severity of Risk, (12) Prioritizes Risks, (13) Implements Risk Responses, and (14) Develops Portfolio View. The risk management system must be comprehensive in accordance with the risk management process. In 2024, the ERM Portfolio of the Hospital is categorized into 5 risk categories:

I. Emerging Risk

II. Business Risk

III. Clinical Risk

IV. ESG Risk

V. Shareholder Risk

4. Review and Revision

The Hospital regularly reviews risks across 5 categories, with risk owners coordinating with the risk management division. This process consists of 3 principles: (15) Assesses Substantial Change, (16) Reviews Risk and Performance, and (17) Pursues Improvement in Enterprise Risk Management.

5. Information, Communication, and Reporting

The Company collects risk-related data, communicates it to employees at all levels, and implements a reporting process based on 3 principles: (18) Leverages Information and Technology, (19) Communicates Risk Information, and (20) Reports on Risk, Culture, and Performance

Policy Document Link

https://investor.praram9.com/en/company-info/sustainability-management/risk-management

Page Number in Report

46 (48)

Risks to the Company's Business Operations

Risk Register

Risk NameRisk CharacteristicsConsequencesManagement MeasuresRelated Risk Factors
Emerging Risk : Cost Conscious

The Health Provider industry in Thailand is highly competitive, with new entrants regularly joining the sector. The ability to remain competitive is measured by an organization's capacity to manage costs effectively and efficiently.

1. Higher costs may reduce competitiveness

2. Hospitals' net profits may decrease if they cannot effectively control costs

3. They may have to increase service prices, affecting the number of service recipients


1. Conduct an in-depth analysis of fixed costs (Fix Cost) to identify the factors contributing to their increase.

2. Develop proactive cost risk management plans.

3. Establish risk indicators to monitor risks periodically.

1714 · Description: Competition risk · Info category: STRATEGIC_RISK
Business Risks : Risk of Failing to Achieve World-Class Hospitality Within 5 Years

The Hospital has a strategic goal of becoming World-Class Hospitality to accommodate international patients, including both tourists and those residing and working in Thailand (Expat). Achieving World-Class Hospitality requires several adaptations, such as ensuring that the quality of treatment is on par with World-Class standard, along with enhancing service quality and staff competency at all levels to achieve this goal.

1. Loss of opportunity to expand the foreign patient market, which is a significant high-potential customer group.

2. Decline in the hospital's image and credibility compared to competitors.

3. Revenue and profits from the foreign customer group falling short of established targets.

1. Treatment Quality: Investing in advanced medical technologies that align with international standards, as well as developing multidisciplinary skills and knowledge. 2. Service Excellence: Analyzing various complaints to identify root causes, enhancing communication skills, fostering an international service culture, and creating incentives for employees.

3. There is regular monitoring and evaluation of risks to improve the quality of service delivery.

729 · Description: Behavior or needs of customers / consumers · Info category: STRATEGIC_RISK · 732 · Description: Changes in technologies · Info category: STRATEGIC_RISK · 742 · Description: Human error in business operations · Info category: OPERATIONAL_RISK
Business risks : Cyber Resiliency

The healthcare service industry is highly vulnerable to cyber threats due to the high value of Personal Health Information (PHI) and Electronic Health Records (EHR) on the dark web. This makes it a primary target for attacks such as ransomware and phishing. These attacks can have severe impacts on patient care, business continuity, and customer trust.

1. Loss or leakage of data may impact patient safety and privacy.

2. Damage to the reputation and credibility of the hospital.

3. Financial losses due to operational disruptions and damage remediation.

4. Disruption in the hospital's workflow, preventing normal operations.

5. Leaked information may lead to legal consequences and associated damages.

Preventive Control Measures:

1. Regular penetration testing.

2. Consistent updates of antivirus software.

3. Educating employees across all departments about cybersecurity.


Detective Control Measures:

1. Structuring the network to ensure continuity in all situations.

2. Monitoring proactive Key Risk Indicators (KRIs), such as:

2.1 System availability uptime.

2.2 Statistics of external and internal attacks that cannot be prevented or resolved.


Recovery Control Measures:

1. Setting a rapid Cyber Resiliency recovery goal.

2. Defining the RTO (Recovery Time Objective) to establish the timeframe for system recovery.

744 · Description: Information security and cyber-attack · Info category: OPERATIONAL_RISK · 1720 · Description: System disruption risk · Info category: OPERATIONAL_RISK
Business Risks : Risk of Workforce Competency Misalignment with Organizational Direction

The business environment is rapidly evolving and requiring a high level of adaptability. As a result, workforce competencies must continuously adjust. The extended timeframe required to develop new competencies could pose a risk, potentially preventing the Hospital from achieving its organizational objectives on time.


If personnel are unable to adapt and develop their competencies in alignment with the organization's direction and goals in a timely manner, it may result in:

1. Reduced work efficiency

2. Patient services not meeting established standards

3. Decreased patient satisfaction

4. Reduced competitiveness in the market

5. Failure to achieve business objectives

1. Established a competency set that aligns with the Hospital's future goals

2. Developed a performance measurement system that integrates these competencies.

3. Human Resource Development (HRD) system has been designed to support these competencies through training and practical application via on-the-job training.

729 · Description: Behavior or needs of customers / consumers · Info category: STRATEGIC_RISK · 739 · Description: Shortage or reliance on skilled workers · Info category: OPERATIONAL_RISK · 742 · Description: Human error in business operations · Info category: OPERATIONAL_RISK
Business Risks : Risk of Non-Compliance with Business-Related Regulations

The risk of non-compliance related to the business operations of Praram 9 Hospital arises from the necessity for the hospital to adhere to continuously emerging regulations and new laws. These include laws at the national level, professional group regulations, and the rules set forth by the Securities and Exchange Commission. Failure to comply with these regulations may result in fines or legal action, which could negatively impact the hospital's reputation and operations.

The impact of non-compliance with regulations related to business operations can be categorized into several aspects, including:


1. Financial Aspect: Being fined or facing legal action could lead to significant expenses for the hospital.

2. Reputational Aspect: Non-compliance may damage the hospital's reputation, affecting the trust of patients and stakeholders.

3. Operational Aspect: Legal proceedings could disrupt the hospital's operations, impacting its ability to provide patient services.

1. Follow new regulations: The hospital continuously follows new regulations and analyzes the stakeholders involved in such regulations.

2. Communicate the guidelines: The hospital systematically communicates the guidelines for compliance with the regulations so that all employees understand and can comply correctly.

3. Educate employees: The hospital educates all employees about new regulations and how to comply with those regulations.

4. Create a flow of implementation: The hospital creates a flow of implementation if there is any non-compliance with the regulations so that it can respond quickly and communicate and clarify quickly if any potential non-compliance is found.

756 · Description: Change in laws and regulations · Info category: COMPLIANCE_RISK · 742 · Description: Human error in business operations · Info category: OPERATIONAL_RISK · 1723 · Description: Legal risk · Info category: COMPLIANCE_RISK
Clinical Risk : Patient Safety

Patient safety is the top priority at Praram 9 Hospital. Patient safety risk refers to the likelihood of patients being harmed during medical services, which may result from errors by personnel, treatment processes, work systems, or other environmental factors. If not managed effectively, these risks can impact patients' lives, the hospital's reputation, and the credibility of the healthcare system.

1. Impact on Patients: Risks in medical services may lead to treatment errors, resulting in prolonged hospitalization for patients and potentially posing life-threatening dangers.

2. Impact on Medical Personnel: Medical staff may experience stress and pressure from dealing with risks and adverse events. This stress can affect their mental health and work performance.

3. Impact on the Organization: Risks in medical services can lead to financial losses from lawsuits and compensation claims. Additionally, it may damage the hospital's reputation and erode trust from patients and the community, ultimately affecting the organization's operations and long-term development.

1.Patient Safety Culture Project : Correct Patient Identification (IPSG1) and IPSG1 Education Training: Focus on the process of correct patient identification.

1.1 Empowering and Engaging Patients and Staff: Promoting a culture of collaboration and learning from patients and personnel.

1.2 Anticipating and Responding to Risks: Identifying risks in advance and responding to risks.

1.3 Reducing Common Causes of Harm: Using information from various sources to recognize and reduce common causes of harm.

1.4 Using Information to Improve Patient Safety: Using information to improve patient safety.

1.5 Leadership and Governance: Cultivating a culture of improving safety through effective leadership and governance .

2. Develop a risk culture by appointing risk coordinators or Risk Champions for each ward to represent their units in fostering a proactive risk culture. These Risk Champions will undergo training to gain valuable knowledge, with the primary goal of enhancing patient safety.

3. Connect risk data across all points through guidance provided by the advisory team, which offers risk knowledge and training on completing the Risk Register.

4. The Risk Management Award 2024 Project: IR (Near Miss) Hunter. Enhancing proactive risk management through the identification of risks in the form of Near Miss. and encourage personnel to participate in finding and reporting risks.

5. The “Voice of Service Recipients for Development” Project Activity: “Risk Management Award 2024” (Outstanding Prevention Champion). Risk Identification is a proactive activity. Also utilizing the PDCA (Plan – Do – Check – Act) and RCA (Root Cause Analysis) processes to prevent recurring risks, including listening to patient feedback to resolve and improve hospital services.

729 · Description: Behavior or needs of customers / consumers · Info category: STRATEGIC_RISK · 742 · Description: Human error in business operations · Info category: OPERATIONAL_RISK · 1723 · Description: Legal risk · Info category: COMPLIANCE_RISK
ESG Risk : (Environment) Climate Change Risk

Climate Change Risks:

1. Physical Risks

1.1 Acute Risks: Immediate risks with severe impacts on hospitals, such as natural disasters and extreme weather events.

- Flooding: Affects infrastructure, medical equipment, power systems, and medical supply logistics, potentially leading to partial service closures.

- Severe storms: Strong winds and heavy rainfall can damage buildings and structures, cause power outages, and disrupt IT systems and medical records.

- Abnormally high temperatures: Increases the workload on air conditioning and cooling systems, raising energy costs and potentially impacting temperature-sensitive medical equipment.

- Wildfires: Degrades air quality, worsening conditions for respiratory and heart disease patients, and may increase the need for specialized medical care.

- Heavy rainfall and landslides: May cut off transportation routes, affecting patient and staff mobility, as well as the delivery of medicines and medical supplies.

1.2 Chronic Risks: Long-term, cumulative risks affecting hospital infrastructure and operations.

- Rising average temperatures: Increases the demand for energy in air conditioning and medical equipment, raising operational costs.

- Changes in rainfall patterns: Could lead to drought conditions, reducing water availability for hospitals and increasing water procurement costs.

- Rising sea levels: Could result in long-term flooding issues, necessitating infrastructure adjustments to cope.

- Deteriorating air quality: Accumulating air pollution may lead to higher rates of respiratory illness admissions and impact staff health.

- Increased frequency of emerging infectious diseases: Changes in temperature and humidity may facilitate the spread of infectious diseases like dengue fever, respiratory illnesses, and zoonotic diseases.

2. Transition Risks

2.1 Policy and Legal: Stricter environmental policies and regulations, such as pollution controls and carbon taxes, may raise operational costs.

2.2 Technology: Investments in clean energy and carbon-reduction technologies may be required to comply with regulations, potentially increasing business expenses.

2.3 Market: Consumer behavior is shifting towards prioritizing hospitals with sustainable environmental practices and services that consider greenhouse gas emissions, necessitating service adaptation strategies.

2.4 Reputation: Meeting stakeholder demands for climate action through initiatives and policies, such as environmental disclosures and GHG emissions reporting (Scope 1, 2, 3), is crucial. Poor tracking and reporting systems may risk losing investor confidence.

1. Infrastructure damage: Floods and storms can damage buildings, public utilities, and medical equipment, requiring significant costs for repairs and preventive measures.

2. Business disruptions: Temporary closures may be necessary, leading to revenue loss and the cancellation of patient appointments.

3. Increased costs: Expenses may rise due to repair costs, insurance premiums, energy expenses, investments in technology, and compliance with environmental regulations.

4. Health impacts on patients and staff: Severe weather conditions can affect respiratory systems and overall health for both patients and healthcare personnel.

5. Loss of competitiveness: Hospitals unable to adapt to environmental standards may face disadvantages in the business landscape.

Measures to reduce impacts and enhance resilience are as follows:

1. Adaptation and mitigation of physical risk impacts

1.1 Risk assessment: Monitoring and analyzing potential physical risks

1.2 Development of sustainable infrastructure: Designing buildings to withstand disasters and investing in sustainable water and energy systems

1.3 Energy and water management: Promoting the use of clean energy and reducing water consumption through the Solar Rooftop project and wastewater recycling 1.4 Emergency preparedness: Developing emergency plans, conducting scenario drills, and flood prevention systems

2. Transition risk management

2.1 Monitoring and complying with government policies: Assessing the impact of new environmental legislation

2.2 Reducing greenhouse gas emissions: Setting emission reduction targets for Scope 1, 2, and 3

2.3 Investing in green technology: Utilizing clean energy and improving energy efficiency

2.4 Developing environmentally friendly health services: Reducing waste and supporting a circular economy.


The hospital has implemented the framework for climate risk disclosure of the Task Force on Climate-Related Financial Disclosures as follows.

1. Governance

1.1 Executives and risk owners jointly oversee the greenhouse gas emission reduction process.

1.2 The Organizational Risk Management Committee and the Sustainability Committee making decisions on key issues.

1.3 The Audit Committee and the Board of Directors acknowledge, provide feedback, and oversee the implementation of the greenhouse gas reduction plan.

2. Strategy Climate risk targets are set in alignment with the organization's strategy, categorized into short-term, medium-term, and long-term goals as follows:

2.1 Short-term goal: Conduct measurement and collection of greenhouse gas emissions data

2.2 Medium-term goal: Analyze of climate risk impact in connection with the organization's financial implications

2.3 Long-term goal: Participate in Science-Based Target to drive progress toward Net-Zero Hospital.

3. Risk Management

3.1 Climate Change Risk is integrated as part of the organization's risk management .

3.2 The risk is identified, assessed, managed, and responded to through various risk management strategies, such as adopting a Low Canonization business model.

4. Metric and Target

4.1 Greenhouse gas emissions data are recorded for Scope 1, 2, and 3.

4.2 Set greenhouse gas emission reduction goals for the short, medium, and long term.

756 · Description: Change in laws and regulations · Info category: COMPLIANCE_RISK · 1717 · Description: ESG risk · Info category: STRATEGIC_RISK · 751 · Description: Impact on the environment · Info category: OPERATIONAL_RISK · 1719 · Description: Climate change and disasters · Info category: STRATEGIC_RISK
ESG Risk : (Social) Health and Safety Risk

The health and safety of employees are crucial factors influencing work efficiency, morale, and the sustainability of an organization. This is especially true in the hospital industry, where employees face risks from infectious diseases that may arise from patient care. They also work in environments that may pose hazards, such as exposure to chemicals, working in areas with inappropriate lighting or noise levels, as well as dealing with work-related stress and accidents during operations.

If there is no proper management of health and safety risks for employees, it may lead to both direct and indirect impacts on employees and the organization, including:

1. Employee Health: Injuries or illnesses caused by work, risks of infection from patients, or health problems due to unsuitable environments may result in employees needing to take temporary or permanent leave.

2. Work Efficiency: An environment that does not support health may lead to decreased employee productivity, accumulated stress, and potentially increased absenteeism or resignations.

3. Organizational Operations: Insufficient employee safety can lead to higher medical and compensation costs, as well as damage to the hospital's image and credibility.

1.Improvement of Health and Safety Policies: Regularly review and update health and safety policies to align with current circumstances and international standards.

Employee

2.Communication and Training: Provide training sessions and activities to raise awareness about safety practices, ensuring employees can perform their duties correctly and safely.

3.Enhancement of the Work Environment: Control lighting, noise levels, and air quality to create a suitable working environment, minimizing health impacts on employees.

4.Safety Monitoring and Inspection: Implement continuous tracking, inspection, and risk assessment systems to reduce the likelihood of accidents and work-related illnesses.

5.Health Support: Offer health care measures such as annual health check-up programs, mental health counseling, and health promotion activities. Provide employees with standard-compliant personal protective equipment (PPE).

749 · Description: Safety, occupational health, and working environment · Info category: OPERATIONAL_RISK · 1722 · Description: Pandemic risk · Info category: OPERATIONAL_RISK
ES Risk : (Social) Human Rights

Praram 9 Hospital places importance on the human rights of its employees and all stakeholders to ensure equality and fairness in the organization. However, without proper supervision, human rights risks may arise, such as discrimination based on gender, age, race, or social status, lack of equal opportunities for career advancement, or violation of employees’ fundamental rights, which may affect job satisfaction and the organization’s image.

1.Employee Satisfaction and Morale: If employees feel they are being treated unfairly, it could lead to decreased morale, lower work efficiency, and higher turnover rates.

2.Legal and Regulatory Aspects: Human rights risks may result in complaints or legal issues, potentially leading to litigation costs and affecting the organization's credibility.

3.Organizational Reputation: If the organization is perceived as lacking practices that support human rights, it could harm its image, resulting in a loss of trust from employees, patients, and other stakeholders.

1.Formulating Human Rights Policy: The hospital has studied and developed a systematic human rights policy to ensure that the organization's operations align with international standards.

2.Promoting Equality and Diversity: The hospital adopts the Diversity and Inclusion Policy, ensuring that employees of all genders are given equal opportunities for promotion and are fairly compensated.

3.Communication and Organizational Culture Building: The hospital fosters a work culture that respects diversity and allows employees to freely express their opinions through meetings, training, and internal activities.

4.Monitoring and Evaluation: The organization supervises, reviews, and evaluates its operations to align with human rights policies. It also provides channels for complaints, ensuring employees can report issues safely and receive appropriate resolutions.

5.Comprehensive Human Rights Risk Assessment (Human Rights Due Diligence: HRDD): This involves evaluating the actual and potential impacts of human rights violations on relevant stakeholders.

733 · Description: Business operations of partners in the supply chain · Info category: STRATEGIC_RISK · 745 · Description: Loss or damage from non-compliance of partners or counterparties · Info category: OPERATIONAL_RISK · 753 · Description: Impact on human rights · Info category: OPERATIONAL_RISK
ESG Risk : (Governance) Governance Risk

Governance risks arise from a lack of transparency or internal control within an organization, which can lead to corruption, bribery, and unfair decisions in the management process. Good governance is essential to maintain the trust of shareholders and stakeholders.

The impact of regulatory risk can affect the organization's reputation, credibility and shareholder trust. If there is corruption or bribery, it can cause patients and stakeholders to lose trust in the organization. In addition, non-compliance can lead to fines or legal action, which will affect the financial performance and lose opportunities for business growth.

To manage governance risks, Phramongkutklao Hospital has implemented measures such as the GRC framework and the 3 Lines of Defense to ensure transparency in governance and reduce corruption. In addition, all levels of staff are trained on compliance and anti-bribery, and regular audits and evaluations of operations are conducted to ensure compliance with the established standards.

759 · Description: Corporate Governance · Info category: COMPLIANCE_RISK

Risks to Securities Holders' Investment

Risk Register

Risk NameRisk CharacteristicsConsequencesManagement MeasuresRelated Risk Factors
Shareholder Risk : Risk of Business Growth Not Meeting Is Goals

The risk of business growth not achieving the target arises from the high competition in the healthcare business. Users have the ability to freely choose their hospital according to their needs, which causes the hospital to face the challenge of creating continuous business growth. If the income growth does not go as planned, it will affect the creation of added value for shareholders. Therefore, Praram 9 Hospital divides its growth strategy into two main groups: Thai patients (Domestic) and international patients (International), using different strategies to stimulate income growth.

1.Hospital revenue and profit may fall short of expectations, affecting the return on equity.

2.Competitiveness may be reduced if the hospital is unable to retain or expand its patient base.

3.Investor and business partner confidence may be reduced if the hospital fails to achieve its growth targets consistently.

The hospital has taken proactive measures to reduce such risks. The strategies are divided into two main groups: domestic patients and international patients.

1. Domestic patients: The hospital uses marketing and customer loyalty programs, such as Buy 1 Get 1 promotions, giving discount coupons to employees to distribute, and giving discount coupons to inpatients (IPDs) to encourage repeat visits. In addition, the hospital closely and frequently monitors revenue to assess performance and adjust strategies accordingly.

2. International patients: The hospital focuses on expanding the market through agents and organizing marketing activities, including organizing events that provide opportunities for doctors to meet and build close relationships with international patients, which increases the opportunity to attract more international patients to use the services.

769 · Other name: Risk of Business Growth Not Meeting Is Goals · Description: Other · Info category: HOLDER_RISK
Contents